If you have decided to try meditating but have only 15 minutes to spare today, which kind of meditation should you choose? A study suggests that beginners may benefit from focusing on their breath or body when time is short, and from observing their thoughts when they have more time.
A research team from the School of Psychology at Liaoning Normal University in China, led by corresponding author Ren Guiqin, examined how the duration and type of meditation affect mind-wandering. Their study was published on 28 October in the international journal Current Psychology.

Which practices reduced mind-wandering after 15 minutes?
The researchers divided people with no meditation experience into groups and asked each to practise one of three techniques: breathing meditation, a body scan or open monitoring meditation. They compared the results with those of a group that did not meditate. Open monitoring meditation involves observing thoughts and sensations as they arise, without fixing attention on a single object such as the breath or trying to hold on to them.
After meditating, participants completed a concentration task: they pressed a button whenever a number appeared on screen, but had to stop at a designated number. The more their attention wandered, the more unevenly they tended to press the button. The researchers used this variation to measure mind-wandering.
After a single 15-minute session, the breathing meditation and body scan groups showed less mind-wandering than the group that had not meditated. There was no difference between the two meditation practices. A 15-minute session of open monitoring meditation produced no clear change.
After 30 minutes, observing thoughts also made a difference
The results changed when the meditation session was extended to 30 minutes. The group practising open monitoring meditation, as well as the breathing meditation and body scan groups, showed less mind-wandering than the group that had not meditated.
The researchers said meditation beginners may need longer sessions of open monitoring meditation to reduce mind-wandering. This may be because it is easier to focus, even for a short time, when there is an anchor such as the breath or body; without one, it can take longer for the mind to settle into observing thoughts.
A 15-minute morning session or 30 minutes in the evening: which should you choose?
The study does not say that one type of meditation is better than another. Rather, it shows that different practices may suit different amounts of time and circumstances. In an age when information and notifications constantly pull our attention in different directions, a practice with a clear focus can act as an anchor, bringing the mind back during a short break.
For a brief spell of around 15 minutes before work or during lunch, try breathing meditation or a body scan. When you have at least 30 minutes to spare, perhaps on a weekend evening or before bed, it may be worth trying to observe your thoughts. If observing your thoughts felt difficult at first, it may not mean meditation is not for you; you may simply have had too little time.

Trying a body scan for the first time: from your toes to the top of your head
If you have chosen a body scan for a 15-minute session, here is one way to begin. Sit back comfortably in a chair or lie on your back on the floor. Take a few slow breaths, then bring your attention to your toes and the soles of your feet. Simply notice whether they feel warm, tingly or numb. Slowly move your attention through your ankles and calves, knees and thighs, then your stomach and chest, shoulders and arms, neck and face, and finally the top of your head. If other thoughts arise, do not criticise yourself; simply return to the part of your body you were focusing on.
For a 30-minute session observing your thoughts, spend the first few minutes focusing on your breathing to settle your mind. Then release your attention from the breath and watch thoughts, sounds and bodily sensations as they arise, like clouds passing across the sky. When you notice that you have started following a thought, take a step back and return to the position of an observer.
On shorter days, focus on the breath and body; when you have more time, observe your thoughts. The time you have available today can help you decide which meditation to choose.
Article enquiries: fare3041@naver.com
